Sugary Drinks: Experts Clash on WHO's Tax Proposal

Table of Contents

The Role of Taxes in Combating Health Risks

Public health experts emphasize that while increasing taxes on sugary and alcoholic drinks can play a role in reducing their consumption, it is not a standalone solution to the broader public health challenges they contribute to. These beverages are linked to non-communicable diseases (NCDs) such as diabetes, obesity, and heart disease, which are major causes of global mortality.

The World Health Organisation (WHO) has long advocated for higher taxes on sugary drinks and alcohol, citing their role in fueling health crises worldwide. According to WHO Director-General Dr. Tedros Ghebreyesus, health taxes have been shown to reduce consumption of harmful products, prevent disease, and generate revenue for public services like health, education, and social protection.

Despite these benefits, experts argue that taxation alone cannot address the complex factors driving NCDs. Prof. Adebayo Onajole, a Public Health Physician, highlights that while taxes may discourage consumption, they do not account for behavioral shifts, especially in low-income populations where affordability plays a significant role. He explains that when disposable income is limited, people often turn to cheaper alternatives, which may still pose health risks.

Beyond Taxation: The Importance of Awareness and Education

Onajole stresses that lifestyle choices, including the consumption of processed foods, also significantly influence the prevalence of NCDs. He points out that studies show a strong correlation between these diseases and dietary habits beyond just sugary drinks and alcohol. Therefore, raising awareness about the dangers of processed foods is essential alongside tax policies.

Dr. Gafar Alawode, another Public Health Physician, echoes this sentiment. He notes that while taxes can reduce consumption, they must be substantial enough to make an impact. Evidence from countries like South Africa and the United Kingdom shows that well-implemented taxes on harmful products lead to reduced intake and lower health risks.

However, Alawode cautions that taxation alone is not sufficient. Public education is equally important. People need to understand the consequences of excessive consumption, whether they are consuming regulated or unregulated products. When individuals are informed, they are more likely to make healthier choices.

Global Concerns: Rising Obesity and NCDs

The WHO has raised alarms about the growing prevalence of childhood obesity, particularly in low- and middle-income countries. In 2022, over 37 million children under five were overweight, and more than 390 million children and adolescents aged 5–19 years were overweight, with 160 million living with obesity. This trend is seen as a critical public health issue that requires urgent attention.

Dr. Matshidiso Moeti, WHO Regional Director for Africa, warns that the continent is facing a rising burden of obesity and overweight conditions. She describes it as a “ticking time bomb,” emphasizing that many of the causes of obesity are preventable and reversible through targeted interventions.

Challenges and Considerations

One concern is that higher taxes might push consumers toward locally produced alternatives that could be even more harmful. However, evidence from other countries suggests that this risk is not as widespread as feared. Most commonly consumed sugary drinks are commercially produced, making them more susceptible to taxation.

Experts agree that a multi-faceted approach is needed. While taxes can help reduce consumption, they must be accompanied by sustained public education campaigns to ensure that citizens understand the long-term health impacts of their choices.

In conclusion, while raising taxes on sugary and alcoholic drinks is a step in the right direction, it is only one part of a larger strategy. Addressing NCDs requires a combination of policy measures, public awareness, and behavioral change to create lasting improvements in public health.