NHS Maternity Review Head Condemns 'Unacceptable Care' in England

Table of Contents

A Critical Examination of Maternity Care in England

The current state of maternity and neonatal care in England has sparked significant concern among experts, families, and healthcare professionals. Baroness Valerie Amos, leading the National Maternity and Neonatal Investigation (NMNI), has expressed shock at the scale of unacceptable care that women and their families have endured. Her findings, based on visits to seven NHS trusts and conversations with families and staff, reveal a system struggling to meet basic standards of safety and compassion.

Baroness Amos highlighted that her expectations were exceeded by the depth of issues uncovered. She emphasized that while she anticipated hearing about failures in care, the extent of the problems was more severe than expected. The tragic consequences for babies and the emotional toll on families are evident, raising urgent questions about why progress has been so slow despite numerous reviews and recommendations.

Over the past decade, 748 recommendations have been made regarding maternity and neonatal care, a number that Baroness Amos finds staggering. This raises an important question: if so many reviews have already been conducted, why is the quality of care still inconsistent? The report outlines recurring issues such as women not being heard, lack of informed choice, and discrimination against certain groups, including women of colour, working-class women, younger parents, and those with mental health challenges.

In addition to these systemic problems, the investigation revealed distressing cases where women who had lost babies were placed on wards with newborns, and concerns about reduced foetal movement were often dismissed. The lack of empathy from clinical teams when things go wrong has left many women feeling blamed and guilty, compounding their trauma.

Baroness Amos acknowledged the courage of families who have shared their experiences, even though some have criticized the probe and called for a statutory public inquiry. Their feedback has been crucial in shaping the investigation, and she remains committed to driving change. She stressed that while the pace of reform has been too slow, it is both possible and necessary to improve the situation.

The NMNI will focus on 12 NHS trusts, with findings expected in 2026. However, some aspects of the probe have faced delays, with a call for evidence initially planned for November now postponed to January. Despite this, Baroness Amos maintains confidence in completing the investigation within the timeline, aiming to produce recommendations for fundamental improvements.

Health Secretary Wes Streeting, who initiated the investigation, acknowledged the devastating impact on families and praised their courage in coming forward. He emphasized the need to address systemic failures that have led to preventable tragedies, while also recognizing the dedication of NHS staff. He is setting up a National Mataternity and Neonatal Taskforce to oversee the response, ensuring that affected families remain central to the process.

Medical negligence lawyer Anne Kavanagh noted that high-profile scandals, such as those at Morecambe Bay and Shrewsbury and Telford hospitals, have long highlighted deep-rooted issues. She pointed out that many recommendations from previous reports have not been fully implemented, missing opportunities to improve patient safety. Baroness Amos's findings serve as a reminder of the urgency for change.

Duncan Burton, Chief Nursing Officer for England, welcomed the investigation as a crucial step toward meaningful reform. He reiterated the commitment to providing safe and compassionate care, urging families to communicate their concerns with midwives and maternity teams.

Angela McConville of the National Childbirth Trust emphasized that while some women have positive experiences, the inconsistency of care is unacceptable. She called for answers to the pressing question: why has change not happened?

As the investigation continues, the focus remains on addressing the systemic failures that have led to preventable tragedies. The path forward requires sustained effort, transparency, and a commitment to ensuring that every woman and baby receives the care they deserve.